Final Greenwashing Guidelines Now Part of the Competition Act
In a landmark move to combat misleading environmental claims, Canada’s Competition Bureau has officially released its final guidelines on greenwashing under the Competition Act. Effective as of June 5, 2025, these rules clarify how businesses must substantiate environmental claims to avoid legal repercussions.
The guidelines follow a comprehensive consultation process and represent a significant step in addressing deceptive marketing practices tied to environmental, sustainability, and governance (ESG) claims. This move aligns with growing global efforts to hold businesses accountable for their environmental assertions.
The new regulations are far-reaching, applying to all types and sizes of businesses, including small enterprises, non-profits, and even foreign companies marketing to Canadians. Notably, there are no exemptions for small businesses or specific organizational structures.
Under the updated Competition Act, sections 74.01(1)(b.1) and 74.01(1)(b.2) now prohibit unsubstantiated environmental claims. Businesses must back their assertions with “proper and adequate tests” or “internationally recognized methodology,” with the burden of proof resting squarely on the entity making the claim.
Enforcement begins on June 20, 2025, with the Competition Tribunal empowered to allow private legal actions against businesses for alleged breaches, provided it serves the public interest. This marks a shift from relying solely on government agencies for enforcement.
The Competition Bureau has emphasized that its focus will be on promotional materials, excluding non-public documents like securities filings. However, private litigants and the Tribunal are not bound by the Bureau’s interpretations, ensuring a robust framework for challenging misleading claims.
For businesses, compliance demands rigorous evidence and documentation to support environmental claims. This applies to all entities, from multinational corporations to local charities, ensuring a level playing field and protecting consumers from misleading information.
The final guidelines underscore the importance of transparency and accountability in environmental marketing. By setting a high bar for substantiation, Canada aims to prevent greenwashing and ensure consumers receive accurate information about the environmental impact of products and services.
These changes signal a new era of regulatory scrutiny, where businesses must be prepared to defend their environmental claims with credible, scientifically sound evidence. Failure to comply could result in legal challenges and reputational damage.
As the guidelines take effect, companies operating in or marketing to Canada must reassess their environmental claims to ensure compliance. The updated rules are designed to foster trust and transparency in the marketplace, aligning with global efforts to combat greenwashing.
For more details on the guidelines and their implications, visit the source link: https://www.canadianlawyermag.com/practice-areas/esg/final-greenwashing-guidelines-now-part-of-the-competition-act/392593.
Understanding the Scope and Requirements of the Guidelines
The Competition Bureau’s final guidelines on greenwashing under the Competition Act are comprehensive in scope, applying to a wide range of entities. This includes businesses of all sizes, from small enterprises to multinational corporations, as well as charitable and non-profit organizations. Additionally, the guidelines extend to foreign businesses that market products or services to Canadians, ensuring that all entities making environmental claims in the Canadian market are held to the same standards.
There are no exemptions for small businesses or specific organizational structures. Any entity, including individuals engaged in business activities, must comply with the Act’s provisions when making environmental claims. This means that whether a business is large or small, for-profit or non-profit, it must ensure that its environmental claims are substantiated and not misleading.
The guidelines outline two key provisions under sections 74.01(1)(b.1) and 74.01(1)(b.2) of the Competition Act. Under section 74.01(1)(b.1), businesses are prohibited from making statements, warranties, or guarantees about a product’s environmental benefits unless such claims are supported by “an adequate and proper test.” The burden of proof for substantiation lies with the party making the claim, meaning businesses must be prepared to provide credible evidence to back up their assertions.
Section 74.01(1)(b.2) extends these requirements to promotional statements about the environmental benefits of a business or its activities. Such claims must be substantiated in accordance with “internationally recognized methodology.” This means that businesses must use widely accepted scientific standards when making broader environmental claims about their operations or practices. Again, the onus is on the entity making the claim to provide proof if challenged.
Enforcement and Legal Process
Enforcement of the new guidelines will begin on June 20, 2025. The Competition Tribunal will have the authority to grant private parties leave to bring legal action against businesses for alleged breaches of these provisions if it determines that such action is in the public interest. This marks a significant shift in enforcement, as it allows individuals and organizations, not just government agencies, to initiate proceedings for misleading environmental claims.
While the Competition Bureau’s guidelines outline its enforcement priorities, it is important to note that the Bureau does not intend to scrutinize securities filings or other non-promotional materials. The focus will be on representations made to promote business interests to the public. However, private litigants and the Competition Tribunal are not bound by the Bureau’s interpretations, ensuring that the enforcement framework remains robust and adaptable to different scenarios.
Substantiation and Methodology
For businesses to comply with the guidelines, they must base their environmental claims on solid evidence and “proper and adequate tests” before making them public. When substantiating broader claims tied to business activities or practices, businesses must use recognized international standards or methodologies. This ensures that claims are credible and aligned with global best practices.
Documentation is also a critical component of compliance. Businesses must retain all data and records used to confirm the truth of their environmental claims, as they bear the burden of proof if challenged. This requirement underscores the importance of maintaining thorough and transparent records to support any environmental assertions made in the marketplace.
Practical Implications for Businesses
The final guidelines have significant implications for businesses operating in Canada. Every environmental claim, regardless of its scale, must be backed by rigorous and credible evidence. This applies equally to multinational corporations and small businesses, as well as to charitable and non-profit organizations. The level playing field ensures that all entities are held to the same standards when making environmental claims.
Failure to adequately substantiate environmental claims can lead to serious consequences, including legal challenges and reputational damage. Businesses must therefore be diligent in ensuring that their claims are accurate and supported by robust evidence. This not only helps to avoid legal repercussions but also builds trust with consumers who are increasingly scrutinizing environmental claims.
Key Takeaways
The Competition Bureau’s final guidelines on greenwashing set a high bar for substantiating environmental marketing claims. The rules apply broadly to all types and sizes of businesses, including those based outside of Canada. This ensures that foreign businesses marketing to Canadians are also held accountable for their environmental claims.
Enforcement mechanisms have been strengthened, allowing not just government agencies but also private parties to challenge misleading claims in the public interest. This shift reflects a growing recognition of the importance of transparency and accountability in environmental marketing.
Businesses must use internationally recognized methodologies when substantiating environmental claims and be prepared to provide proof if challenged. These requirements are designed to foster transparency, prevent misleading green marketing practices, and ensure that consumers receive accurate information about the environmental impacts of products and businesses operating in Canada.
Conclusion
The Competition Bureau’s final guidelines on greenwashing under the Competition Act represent a significant step towards combating misleading environmental claims in Canada. By applying to all businesses regardless of size or structure, and extending to foreign entities marketing to Canadians, these guidelines ensure a level playing field. The emphasis on substantiation through proper tests and internationally recognized methodologies underscores the importance of transparency and accountability. The shift in enforcement, allowing private parties to bring legal actions, highlights a growing commitment to consumer protection and truthful marketing. As businesses adapt to these guidelines, they must prioritize rigorous evidence and clear communication to maintain consumer trust and avoid legal repercussions.
FAQ
-
Who do the Competition Bureau’s greenwashing guidelines apply to?
The guidelines apply to all businesses operating in Canada, including small businesses, multinational corporations, and non-profit organizations, as well as foreign entities marketing to Canadians. -
When will the enforcement of the new guidelines begin?
Enforcement of the guidelines will start on June 20, 2025. -
What kind of proof is required to substantiate environmental claims?
Businesses must base their environmental claims on solid evidence from “proper and adequate tests” or internationally recognized methodologies, depending on the type of claim. -
What are the consequences of failing to comply with the guidelines?
Non-compliance can lead to legal challenges, reputational damage, and loss of consumer trust. -
Can private individuals or organizations bring legal actions for greenwashing?
Yes, the Competition Tribunal can grant private parties leave to bring legal actions if it is deemed to be in the public interest.
